Monterey Pop vs. The Complete
Monterey Pop Festival [Blu-ray]
(D.A.
Pennebaker, 1968)
|
|

|
 |


Also released in the UK, on
Blu-ray
by Criterion, one week later on December 18th, 2017

|
Review by Mizzou +
Gary Tooze
Studio:
Theatrical: The Foundation
Blu-ray: Criterion Collection Spines
#168 + 169
Disc:
Region: 'A'-locked
in US 'B' in UK
(as verified by the
Momitsu region FREE Blu-ray player)
Runtime: 1:19:29.181
/ 1:19:30.015
Disc Size: 49,708,485,793 bytes
/ 47,025,887,875 bytes
Feature Size: 33,676,413,440 bytes
/ 28,156,397,568 bytes
Video Bitrate: 18.10 Mbps
/ 35.66 Mbps
Chapters: 20
/ 20
Case: Standard Blu-ray case
/ Transparent Blu-ray Case
Release date: September 22nd, 2009
/ December 12th, 2017
Video (both):
Aspect ratio: 1.33:1 matted to 1.78
Resolution: 1080p / 23.976 fps
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC Video
Audio:
DTS-HD Master Audio English 1509 kbps 5.1 / 48 kHz / 24-bit
(DTS Core: 5.1 / 48 kHz / 1509 kbps / 24-bit)
LPCM Audio English 2304 kbps 2.0 / 48 kHz / 2304 kbps /
24-bit
LPCM Audio English 2304 kbps 2.0 / 48 kHz / 2304 kbps /
24-bit
Commentary:
Dolby Digital Audio English 224 kbps 2.0 / 48 kHz / 224 kbps
LPCM Audio English 2304 kbps 2.0 / 48 kHz / 2304 kbps /
24-bit
LPCM Audio English 2304 kbps 2.0 / 48 kHz / 2304 kbps /
24-bit
DTS-HD Master Audio English 4352 kbps 5.1 / 48 kHz / 4352
kbps / 24-bit (DTS Core: 5.1 / 48 kHz / 1509 kbps / 24-bit)
Commentary:
Dolby Digital Audio English 192 kbps 2.0 / 48 kHz / 192 kbps
Subtitles (both):
N one
Extras :
• Audio commentary by Festival
producer Lou Adler and Pennebaker
• Video interview with Adler and
Pennebaker
• Audio interviews with festival
producer John Phillips, festival
publicist Derek Taylor, and
performers Cass Elliot and David
Crosby
• Photo-essay by photographer Elaine
Mayes
• Original theatrical trailer and
radio spots
• Monterey Pop Festival scrapbook
• A booklet featuring essays by
critics Michael Lydon, Barney
Hoskyns, and Armond White
•
Audio
commentaries from 2002 featuring
Pennebaker, festival producer Lou
Adler, and music critics Charles
Shaar Murray and Peter Guralnick
•
New
interviews with Adler (11:48) and
Pennebaker (14:50)
•
Chiefs
(1968), a short film by Richard Leacock, which played alongside
Monterey Pop in theaters (19:52)
•
Interviews from 2002 with Adler and
Pennebaker and with Phil Walden,
Otis Redding’s manager
(29:22)
•
1987
interview with Pete Townshend on
Monterey and Jimi Hendrix (4:40)
•
Audio
interviews with festival producer
John Phillips (16:02), festival
publicist Derek Taylor (29:23), and
performers Cass Elliot (12:19) and
David Crosby (9:27)
•
Photo-essay by Elaine Mayes (12:15)
•
Festival scrapbook
• Trailers
(2:44 + 2:27) and radio spots (3:41)
Second disc
of:
•
Two hours of
performances not included in
Monterey Pop, from the Association,
Big Brother and the Holding Company,
the Blues Project, Buffalo
Springfield, the Paul Butterfield
Blues Band, the Byrds, Country Joe
and the Fish, the Electric Flag, the
Grateful Dead, Jefferson Airplane,
Al Kooper, the Mamas and the Papas,
the Steve Miller Blues Band, Moby
Grape, Laura Nyro, Quicksilver
Messenger Service, Simon and
Garfunkel, Tiny Tim, and the Who
PLUS: A book featuring essays by
critics Michael Chaiken, Armond
White, David Fricke, Barney Hoskyns,
and Michael Lydon
The Film:
"Monterey Pop"...is a contemporary
music film—in the relatively fresh
tradition of "Festival" and "Don't
Look Back." The movie, filmed by
Richard Leacock and D. A. Pennebaker,
with the collaboration of Albert
Maysles and other independent
filmmakers, is an upbeat, color
documentary of the 1967 pop-music
festival in Monterey, Calif. It
stars the Mamas and the Papas, the
Jefferson Airplane, Ravi Shankar,
the Who and other singing groups.
From the moment Scott Mackenzie's
"If you're going to San Francisco"
comes onto the track and screen, it
is clear that this is one good way
to do a musical.
Excerpt of review from Renata Alder
located HERE
Image:
NOTE:
The below
Blu-ray
captures were taken directly from the
Blu-ray
disc.
As the accompanying
booklet tells us, the print print
was transferred from the "original
16 mm camera reversal and the 35 mm
duplicate negative". The fact that
the film was originally shot with a
16 mm camera accounts for some of
the softness in certain scenes and
the overall grainy appearance of the
film. But don't be fooled by this
fact. The image here is by far the
best that the film will ever look,
easily running circles around the
standard definition release from
2002. What's more, the print, which
was supervised by Pennebaker
himself, showcases the loving care
that Criterion put into this
release, removing as the booklet
states, thousands of instances of
dirt and damage. Although there are
a few instances of damage that still
crop up, they are very minor and not
distracting in the least. Overall,
this is a very impressive effort and
indicative of why Criterion has come
out as one of the early leaders in
Blu-ray
picture quality.
To clear up the packages; There are
two in 2017 being released by
Criterion. "The Complete Monterey
Pop Festival" is a three
Blu-ray disc package.
There is also a 2017 single
Blu-ray disc new
release that is only the first disc
of the 'Complete'. Both have
'New 16-bit 4K digital
restorations'. The 'Complete'
has a second disc of
two hours of
performances not included in
Monterey Pop, from the Association,
Big Brother and the Holding Company,
the Blues Project, Buffalo
Springfield, the Paul Butterfield
Blues Band, the Byrds, Country Joe
and the Fish, the Electric Flag, the
Grateful Dead, Jefferson Airplane,
Al Kooper, the Mamas and the Papas,
the Steve Miller Blues Band, Moby
Grape, Laura Nyro, Quicksilver
Messenger Service, Simon and
Garfunkel, Tiny Tim, and the Who
plus other new extras. It also
contains a 3rd
Blu-ray
of Jimi Plays Monterey / Shake!
Otis At Monterey that appears to
be the exact same as the 2009 HD
edition we reviewed
HERE
and shows matching captures at the
bottom of this review.
The
'New 16-bit 4K digital
restoration' is a big step up
from the 2009 transfer as you can
see by the matched screen captures
below. Color are richer, bitrates
are almost double, grain more
consistent and there is more
information in the frame. It looks
significantly superior in-motion.
Hard to believe it could look so
much improved... but it does.
CLICK EACH
BLU-RAY
CAPTURE TO SEE ALL IMAGES IN FULL 1920X1080 RESOLUTION
1)
Criterion Collection (2009) - Blu-ray
TOP
2)
Criterion Collection (2017 )- Blu-ray
BOTTOM
|
1)
Criterion Collection (2009) - Blu-ray
TOP
2)
Criterion Collection (2017 )
- Blu-ray
BOTTOM
|
1)
Criterion Collection (2009) - Blu-ray
TOP
2)
Criterion Collection (2017 )- Blu-ray
BOTTOM
|
1)
Criterion Collection (2009) - Blu-ray
TOP
2)
Criterion Collection (2017 )
- Blu-ray
BOTTOM
|
1)
Criterion Collection (2009) - Blu-ray
TOP
2)
Criterion Collection (2017 )
- Blu-ray
BOTTOM
|
1)
Criterion Collection (2009) - Blu-ray
TOP
2)
Criterion Collection (2017)
- Blu-ray
BOTTOM
|
More 2017
Blu-ray Captures
Blu-ray Captures from
Disc 2
Audio & Music:
For this release, sound engineer
Eddie Kramer remixed the concert's
original 8-Track recordings and in
the process cleaned up all of the
hisses, pops, and cracks that
plagued them. The soundtrack is
offered in three different versions,
an original and remixed uncompressed
stereo mix, and a remixed DTS-HD
Master Audio 5.1. In my estimation,
the last track is easily the way to
go. The songs really come to life
here and, well, everything sounds
about as crisp and clear as it
possibly can. While it may sound
hyperbolic, I can honestly say that
this is likely the best sounding
track that I've ever encountered on
a disc. It's a perfect 10 out of 10.
While the linear PCM audio transfers
are, technically, the same, the
DTS-HD Master 5.1 bump is far more
robust and sounds amazing - rich,
floor-rattling deep and loud. There
are still no subtitle - nor the need
for them. The US
Blu-ray edition is
Region 'A' and the UK
Blu-ray is Region 'B'.
Extras:
At the time that Criterion released
this on DVD, it was one of their
most impressive packages that they
had ever put together. Now, 8 years
later, that still holds true. This
disc is filled to the brims with
extra features that cover both the
inception of the concert, the
concert itself, and its effect on
pop culture. Of most value in my
opinion is the commentary track
featuring Pennebaker and concert
co-producer Lou Adler. Sadly,
co-producer John Philips of the
Mamas and the Papas was originally
scheduled to take part in the
commentary but was too sick to do so
at the time of the recording. The
commentary covers a wide range of
issues and gives you a good idea of
what it was like to stage and film
the concert. Next we get a series of
interviews. Pennebaker and Adler
recorded video interviews for this
release back in 2001, and there are
also fascinating audio only
interviews with John Phillips, Cass
Elliot, David Crosby, and Derek
Taylor. Next, there is what the disc
labels as "Festival Ephemera",
consisting of pictures taken by
photographer Elaine Mayes and stills
from the original festival program
that have to be seen to be believed.
Also included are a series of
theatrical trailers and radio spots,
along with information on the
Monterey International Pop Festival
Foundation. Next, there's a 46 page
booklet featuring essays
commissioned for the 2002 release.
Last, but certainly not least,
there's roughly two hours worth of
amazing outtakes from the performers
at the show.
Note: Criterion has chosen to
release two editions of this film.
"The Complete Monterey Pop Festival"
contains the additional shorts "Jimi
Pays Monterey" and "Shake: Otis at
Monterey" (Reviewed
HERE) and this set,
which does not contain them.
NOTE: But
is also part of the 2017 3
Blu-ray
"The Complete Monterey Pop
Festival" package.
The extras, and commentary, of the
2009
Blu-ray are here plus
new
interviews with Adler (11:48) and Pennebaker (14:50)
as well as
Chiefs
(1968), the 20-minute short film by Richard Leacock, which played alongside
Monterey Pop in theaters .
There are other tidbits but the big
addition is
a second disc of two hours of
performances not included in
Monterey Pop, from the Association,
Big Brother and the Holding Company,
the Blues Project, Buffalo
Springfield, the Paul Butterfield
Blues Band, the Byrds, Country Joe
and the Fish, the Electric Flag, the
Grateful Dead, Jefferson Airplane,
Al Kooper, the Mamas and the Papas,
the Steve Miller Blues Band, Moby
Grape, Laura Nyro, Quicksilver
Messenger Service, Simon and
Garfunkel, Tiny Tim, and the Who
(see captures above). It also
contains a 3rd
Blu-ray of Jimi
Plays Monterey / Shake! Otis At
Monterey that appears to be the
exact same as the 2009 HD edition we
reviewed
HERE
and shows matching caps at the
bottom of this review.
Criterion Collection (2009) - Blu-ray
Criterion Collection (2017)
- Blu-ray
Bottom line:
As I've already said, this was one
of Criterion's most impressive
releases on DVD, and the jump to HD
only makes it better. Monterey Pop
was arguably the greatest music
festival of all time, and this
package makes you feel like you were
there. I give this my highest
recommendation and encourage all
music lovers to make sure that this
is in their collection.
An amazing
package that you can't turn off once
it's started. My advice, for what
it's worth, don't mess around and
get the single -disc - you will be
missing out on amazing 2 hours of
performances and
3rd
Blu-ray of Jimi
Plays Monterey / Shake! Otis At
Monterey. The Hendrix stuff,
alone, is absolutely fascinating.
Buy with a high degree of
anticipation. This will get many
'Year End' votes in our Poll.
Mesmerizing.
Mizzou
February 18th, 2010
Gary Tooze
December 2017
Directed by
D.A. Pennebaker
USA 1986/87
Jimi Hendrix and Otis Redding arrived in California virtually unknown. Returning
stateside from London, where he had moved to launch his musical career, Hendrix
exploded at Monterey, flooring an unsuspecting audience with his maniacal
six-string pyrotechnics. Redding, venerable star of Memphis’ Stax record label,
seduced the “love crowd” in one of his best—and last—performances.
Jimi Plays
Monterey and Shake! Otis at Monterey feature the entire Monterey sets of these
legendary musicians, performances that have entered rock and roll mythology. |
Posters
Theatrical Release: September 7th, 1986 - Toronto
Film Festival
Jimi Plays Monterey -
Reviews
More
Reviews
DVD
Reviews
Shake!: Otis at Monterey -
Reviews
More
Reviews
DVD
Reviews
Comparison :
|