Review by Leonard Norwitz
Studio:
Theatrical: View Askew
Blu-ray: The Weinstein Company Home Entertainment
Disc:
Region: All
Runtime: 97 min.
Chapters: 16
Size: 50 GB
Case: Standard Blu-ray case
Release date: February 3, 2009
Video:
Aspect ratio: 1080p
Resolution: 1080p
Video codec: AVC @ about 25 Mbps
Audio:
English Dolby TrueHD 5.1. English & French Dolby Digital 5.1
Subtitles:
English SDH & Spanish
Extras:
• Feature Commentary with Director Kevin Smith, Producer
Scott Mosier, and DP Kevin Klein
• Feature Commentary with Director Kevin Smith, Producer
Scott Mosier, and Actors Jeff Anderson, Trevor Fehrman,
Jason Mewes, Brian O'Halloran and Jennifer Schwalbach
• Podcast Commentary with Director Kevin Smith, Producer
Scott Mosier, and Actor Jeff Anderson.
• Deleted Scenes Prepared by Kevin Smith (38:24)
• A Closer Look at Interspecies Erotica (8:58)
• BD Live
• Disc 2:
• Documentary: Back to the Well: Clerks II (97 minutes)
• 10 Train Wrecks: Video Production Diaries (50:47)
• Clerks II: VH1 Movie Special (19:33)
• Blooper Reel (29:55)
The Film:
7
If you prick us, do we not bleed? Even though we talk dirty
and are high on living the life of a slacker, do we not
love? Can we not love? Should we not love?
If we wondered why Lucky (Fred Astaire) keeps Pop (Victor
Moore) around as a pal in Swing Time, considering how much
damage he does, what do we make of Randal (Jeff Anderson)
who absentmindedly causes the fiery destruction of the Quick
Stop managed by Dante (Brian O'Halloran). But no matter,
Dante is about to be married to a rich sexy lady (Jennifer
Schwalbach) and move from dreary New Jersey to sunny Miami –
without Randal. These guys have been best friends since the
original Clerks a dozen years ago, but all that is about to
go bye-bye.
But before the big day, both Dante and Randal put in a month
at Mooby's fast foods, doing what they do best, which is as
little as possible. Dante gives off all the signs that he's
ready to give up his previously pointless life and do the
grownup thing, but Randal, like a heat-seeking missile,
finds any and every possible opportunity to make himself
obnoxious to any customer that does or doesn't not give him
an opening, but most relentlessly to his fellow clerk and
lifelong nerd, Elias (Trevor Fehrman).
While "12-Step" Jay (Jason Mewes) and Silent Bob (Kevin
Smith) stand guard out front, Mooby's manager, Becky
(Rosario Dawson), drops by. We see that Dante appears to
have an easier relationship with her than with his intended.
Moreover, it is she who brings to the movie what level of
maturity it musters. Director Kevin Smith has his hands full
balancing the silliness, the smut,the drug-related humor and
relentless dueling cultural riffs on the one hand with
questions about what to do with one's life after 30 –
really. But he manages better than we might expect given the
first fifteen minutes.
The question that comes up for me with movies like Clerks,
Zack and Miri, and Knocked Up is: what is the takeaway for
the target audience? Do the people (mostly guys) that roll
on the floor in nonstop laughter, respond to the romance as
written, or do they interpret the outcome simply as: smutty
shlub gets hot girl. Or, are these movies, intentionally or
not, instructional: Do they introduce the notion of romance
to guys who never gave it a thought and maybe even affect
their thinking and behavior without their even being aware
of it?
I haven't quite made up my mind about Kevin Smith, but I'm
inclined to believe that the lazy, who-gives-a-fuck persona
that he projects in interviews and the bonus features on
this and other videos is just a cover. Not that he isn't
laid back, but that I think he doesn't want to let on how
much skill and discipline is necessary – even for grossout
comedy.
Image:
6/7
The first number indicates a relative level of excellence
compared to other Blu-ray video discs on a ten-point scale.
The second number places this image along the full range of
DVD and Blu-ray discs.
Kevin makes a point in one of the commentaries that what we
see is what was intended. That's nice, because as far as it
goes, the transfer seems just fine, even if the material
transferred is pretty thin stuff much of the time. I'm
delighted that the outdoor/indoor exposures and color
balances are as correct as they are, but the result is still
flat and uninteresting.
Audio & Music:
7/7
Clerks II is a dialogue-driven affair with dollops of pop
music thrown in for good measure. It's good that we have the
option of uncompressed audio so that we can hear all that is
intended, not that any of it is demonstration material. On
the other hand, we wouldn't and shouldn't expect otherwise.
I figure anything that doesn't drive me to watch a movie
with subtitles in my own language is a plus, especially when
it comes to overlapping dialogue.
Operations:
6
Along with Zack and Miri Makes a Porno this is among the
longest loading discs in recent centuries, and just when you
think things have settled down, there's another file set to
load. Happy am I for having a PS3. Aside from that I'm
delighted with the checkboxes for selecting the desired
extra feature on the main feature window, but puzzled why a
different and far less clear methodology is presented for
its other feature windows.
Extras:
8
In more than you could ever want to know about the making of
Clerks II on two discs, across three (count them!) full
length audio commentaries – one of which was recorded at
about the same time as the movie release as a podcast
(listen while at the cineplex); and in variable quality
standard def: the 90-minute "Back to the Well" which
explores Kevin's history in film from the failed Jersey Girl
to this point, a half-hour blooper reel (with or without
Kevin's comments), and video production diaries – all very
entertaining, dude.
Bottom line:
8
For fans of the genre and of Kevin Smith and his pirate
company in particular, this Blu-ray edition of Clerks II is
indispensable. Added to the hours of extra features, this is
as good a picture, such as it is, as we're going to see for
some years to come – and beyond, I imagine. A must own.
Leonard Norwitz
February 1st, 2009