Review by Leonard Norwitz
Studio:
Theatrical: The Disney Channel
Blu-ray: Walt Disney Studios Home Entertainment
Disc:
Region: A
Runtime: 88 minu
Chapters: 16
Size:
Case: Standard Blu-ray case w/slipcover
Release date: December 16, 2008
Video:
Aspect ratio: 1.78:1
Resolution: 1080p
Video codec: AVC
Audio:
English 5.1 Uncompressed (48kHz/16-bit). English & Spanish
Dolby Digital 5.1
Subtitles:
EEnglish SDH & Spanish
Extras:
• Cheetah Spots: watch the movie with pop-up trivia
• Exclusive Music Sequence featuring Feels Like Love
• Rock-Along mode: sing along with your favorite songs
• 3 Music Videos (11:10)
• Bloopers
• Glitter Temporary Tattoos
The Film:
4
The Cheetah Girls: One World is the second sequel to the
Disney Channel's 2003 hit TV movie. It's the first without
Raven Symoné (sadly, many say) and it kicked off a ten week
tour that began in October. Based on a series of books by
Deborah Gregory, the movies are an excuse for the girls (Chanel:
Adrienne Bailon, 25; Aqua: Kiely Williams, 22; and Dorinda:
Sabrina Bryan, 24) to sing (though not really) and dance
(more like an aerobics workout) and parade around in young
fashions (as if born to the purple.) The first sequel was
set in Spain, the new movie in India: Mumbai, no less. So
the movie is interesting at least as an exercise in
geography in the context of current events, though there
isn't the slightest hint of politics or racial or cultural
concerns anywhere – thus the title, I'm guessing.
The question for the Cheetahs is whether they can manage
their various competing dreams of school, boys, and stardom,
let alone realize them. As our story opens here in the U.S.,
the Cheetahs, who haven't scored a gig after scores of
auditions, are presented with the chance of a lifetime: to
star in a Bollywood movie – that's Bollywood, not Hollywood,
a mistake Chanel mistakes right off. But once they get their
hearts and minds on the same page, the girls are off to
India and the "movie-making capital of the world."
Once there, however, they learn that the producer of the
movie, who also happens to be the director's uncle, has
budgeted for only one star, not a trio. The director
desperately seeks a way to persuade his uncle to consider
all of them (though no one ever thinks to ask if the girls
would be willing to divide their salary between them). As
the movie unfolds, Chanel and Vikram the director (Michael
Steger) start to hit it off; Rahim, the Indian star of the
movie (Rupak Ginn) obsesses about his crush on Gita, the
choreographer (Deepti Daryanani); Aqua hooks up with her
computer phone tech who, in one of the movie's few adult
gags, happens to be Indian (Kunal Sharma); and Dorinda
continues to not answer her phone, knowing it's the Spaniard
she connected with in the previous movie.
The Cheetah Girls are madly popular with kids between 6-14,
which is a considerable buying market - but, except for
they're being attractive and moderately talented, I can't
see as how there is much to the Cheetah movies that would
interest anyone much older. I have to say that as a
concerned citizen and adult, I object to the "attitude"
these girls project as American ambassadors. It's no wonder
that kids grow up with the kind of entitled, me-first,
making-it at all costs attitude many seem to have if an
influential entity such as Disney underwrites it. If I were
a parent to young children, I'd be watching these movies
with my children just to try to filter some of what I
consider bad role modeling
As for the movie, even though the setting here is Bollywoood,
I found little that captures the true Bollywoood flavor –
rather the Cheetahs imposed their aggressive, sassy style on
the Indians, which struck me as an opportunity missed.
Unintentionally, there is one thing this movie does have in
common with typical Bollywood musicals: no one is actually
singing – or at least they don't appear to be. I see lips
move, but they aren't making the physical condescension that
is required for singing. Unhappily, the lip-syncing is none
to good. I've attended Indian Superstar concerts close-up,
and was astonished to learn that no one on stage is singing
either: every song is prerecorded, and all that the
performers do is lip sync and dance about – that they can
do. But the thing that really bowled me over was that the
audience was in on this charade. No one really believed they
were singing, nor were the people on stage the ones on the
recordings. I was told that the intent was an integration of
perfection. It was like Singin' in the Rain meets
Brave New World.
Image:
8/8
The first number indicates a relative level of excellence
compared to other Blu-ray video discs on a ten-point scale.
The second number places this image along the full range of
DVD and Blu-ray discs.
The image is as lush, vivid and warm-toned as a Coppertone
commercial, and just as squeaky clean. There is a quiet haze
over the image that wouldn't begin to remotely interfere
with the movie's enjoyment by the target audience.
Audio & Music:
5/4
Despite its uncompressed audio track, the mix is
surprisingly flat and front-and-center-directed, even in the
big musical numbers. My biggest problem with the music,
besides that so little of the material was fresh is that all
the girls sound so nearly alike. It's not just a question of
style, though that's a big part of it, it's that the audio
processing insists on their being indistinguishable, which
for me was just another contributing factor to my boredom.
Operations:
9
The menu is simple and self-guiding. Even an adult could
make sense of it. Most of the windows have brief summaries
of the content, including length.
Extras:
4
There are the usual bloopers, which will have the target
audience giggling, I'm so very sure, and three "Music
Videos" of "One World," "Cheetah Love" and "Dance With Me"
that are almost indistinguishable from the analogous content
of the movie. There is also a pop-up trivia feature that can
be activated from the bonus features page.
Bottom line:
5/3
The movie is more or less harmless, but decidedly unoriginal
and remarkably unaffected by Bollywood. The script has a few
plotholes that I imagine wouldn't get past the average kid,
though I still can't fathom the popularity of this group
considering how undistinguished they are – as, say, compared
to Miley Cyrus or any of the stars from HSM. For us
fuddy-duddies, it was nice to see Roshan Seth as the uncle
(Seth was in A Passage to India, Indiana Jones and the
Temple of Doom and played Pandit Nehru in Gandhi.) The
locations are stunning and look great on this otherwise
unrecommendable Blu-ray.
Leonard Norwitz
December 20th, 2008