Review by Leonard Norwitz
Studio:
Theatrical: Treehouse Films
Blu-ray: Touchstone Home Entertainment
Disc:
Region: All
Runtime: 122 min
Chapters: 12
Size: 50 GB
Case: Standard Blu-ray case
Release date: January 13, 2009
Video:
Aspect ratio: 2.40:1
Resolution: 1080p
Video codec: AVC
Audio:
English 5.1 DTS-HD (48kHz/24-bit), Spanish DD 5.1 Surround
Subtitles:
Feature & Bonus: English SDH & Spanish
Extras:
• Commentary by Writer/Director Joshua Michael Stern &
Writer Jason Richman
• Inside the Campaign: The Politics of Production (12:43)
• Deleted & Extended Scenes (10:28)
• Previews in HD
The Film:
7
With the 2008 American presidential election just behind us,
Swing Vote sets up the unlikely – one might even say,
implausible – scenario by which the election, now in an
electoral college dead heat, comes down to the vote of one
man whose ballot was caught in an electrical malfunction.
Since New Mexico's rules, we are told, allows for the
recasting of the vote "in a timely manner", the two
presidential candidates – the incumbent Republican played by
Kelsey Grammer, and the Democrat, played by Dennis Hopper –
arrive in Texaco, New Mexico (where the smartest person
appears to be Costner's daughter) to court – make that:
pander to – er, make that: bribe – that one vote.
Ordinarily I am not a fan of Kevin Costner. I can count the
number of movies I like him in on one hand (Silverado,
No Way Out, JFK, The Untouchables and
Field of Dreams). To which group I must now add:
Swing Vote.
I like what San Francisco Chronicle's Mike LaSalle had to
say about the, so I'll quote him a bit:
"It's not easy to play a stupid guy. The temptations are
everywhere - to wink at the audience as if to say, "I'm
smart, actually" - or to try to make being stupid a form of
adorable. Kevin Costner plays a good-natured idiot in "Swing
Vote," a middle-aged man who has squandered what little
potential he had in favor of life as a hard-drinking
good-for-nothing, and he gives a remarkable performance.
The movie's real interest isn't in political issues so much
as in presenting Bud as an archetype of a certain kind of
American, living on the fringes, with little sense of the
world around him. The script, by Jason Richman and director
Joshua Michael Stern, is very good at showing us the thought
patterns of a guy who really doesn't know how life works or
how to comport himself outside his limited sphere. The
scenes between Bud and the political honchos that come
courting him are painfully accurate portrayals of someone
whose social compulsion is to bring everything down to a
comfortable level of clowning, even if it means being
perceived as a buffoon. Costner has the internal workings of
this guy down, and he's well matched by young Madeline
Carroll, who plays his precocious, loving daughter, an
adult's mind in a child's body."
Excerpt of review from SF Chronicle located HERE
Image:
7/8
The first number indicates a relative level of excellence
compared to other Blu-ray video discs on a ten-point scale.
The second number places this image along the full range of
DVD and Blu-ray discs.
I found many of the outdoor shots - as photographed, more
than likely - more overexposed than I thought right. I
checked the image on other displays and I admit that my
set-up is a touch bright and contrasty. (I just installed a
new projector and it won't be calibrated for a couple weeks
yet. If this results in a re-evaluation I shall update my
remarks.) I realize we're in the desert here, but I felt the
brightness was carrying things a little too far. Otherwise,
the desaturated picture has some intentional grain (again,
the desert sand, I imagine), and it's sharp, sometimes
enough so to result in the occasional, fleeting halo.
Audio & Music:
7/7
For this dialogue-driven movie, the DTS-HD mix does the job
nicely: it renders voices clearly, well-located, and
properly balanced. The surrounds don't really have much to
do except supply a faint aura of ambience. The music s off
with sensible dynamic range – it never gets in the way, yet
offers strong support.
Operations:
7
Busy, but unanimated clever menus, where every click comes
down like a guillotine. Lots of information, though, with
every pop-up window.
Extras:
5
There's not a lot here, but I don't see as how a movie like
this expects more. There's a pleasant enough commentary by
writer/director Joshua Michael Stern & co-writer Jason
Richman where they discuss the cast and production but,
curiously, refrain from delving into the politics. The
featurette: "Inside the Campaign" is more or less EPK stuff
glossing over casting and locations. It's nice that all the
extras are in HD, but none of them are must-sees.
Bottom line:
7
Think: Gary Ross & Ivan Reitman's 1993 film, Dave -
much grimmer and without the charm. Dave is political
fantasy that avoids making a point. Swing Vote is a lesson
in social responsibility in a stew of political satire. It
loses it's way briefly, but gets back on track and somehow
manages a satisfying ending. I'd give this video a thumb's
up if it weren't for the image.
Leonard Norwitz
January 10, 2009