Review by Leonard Norwitz
Studio:
Theatrical: 20th Century Fox
Blu-ray: 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment
Disc:
Region: A
Runtime: 90 minu
Chapters: 24
Size: 50 GB
Case: Standard Amaray Blu-ray case
Release date: November 25, 2008
Video:
Aspect ratio: 1.85:1
Resolution: 1080p
Video codec: AVC @ 36 Mbps
Audio:
English DTS HD 5.1 Master Audio. Dolby Digital English,
Spanish & French 5.1
Subtitles:
English, Spanish, Cantonese, Mandarin & Korean
Extras:
• Featurette: The Making of Meet Dave in HD (22:29)
• Crew Profiles (1:54:41)
• Gag Reel in HD (2:42)
• Deleted Scenes in HD (2:25)
• Alternate Ending in HD (0:47)
• Fox Movie Channel Presents: Life After Film School with
Director Brian Robbins in SD (28:58)
• Fox Movie Channel Presents: Making a Scene in SD (9:54)
• Fox Movie Channel Presents: World Premier in SD (4:35)
The Film:
The view from the critics:
The story line is hardly original: Dave is a visitor from
another planet let loose on Manhattan. But it's a perfect
setup for Murphy, who must show Dave attempting to imitate
New Yorkers. . . It wouldn't be an Eddie Murphy movie if he
didn't get to play a couple of roles. Besides being an
alien, Murphy also is the captain of an unusual vessel from
outer space: Dave himself. Within him are dozens of
Lilliputians, each 2 inches tall, scurrying around trying to
make sure Dave is shipshape. –
Ruthe Stein – SF Chronicle.
Eddie Murphy — was that Oscar nominated performance in
Dreamgirls just something I imagined? — continues to trash
his very real talent with bottomfeeding material. In Meet
Dave, Murphy limits himself to two roles (none human). He
plays a pint-sized alien from outer space and the spacecraft
he rode in on. If you think I'm going to explain that lame
premise, think again. But know this: Murphy, teaming again
with his Norbit director Brian Robbins, is assuming we'll
all line up for lazyass toilet jokes and pay for the
privilege. –
Peter Travers, Rolling Stone.
Some movies demand flow charts. Are you under the age of 11
and instantly amused by the notion of a spaceship that looks
like Eddie Murphy, captained by a tiny Eddie Murphy and a
crew of Spandex-clad explorers? If you answered "yes,"
proceed to Meet Dave. (And if you're amused by the notion of
a character called "Lieutenant Buttocks," don't waste any
time reading the rest of this review.) If you answered "no,"
you're likely to spend much of the film silently asking
questions. Why, for instance, would humanoid aliens whose
culture has so much in common with Earth's spend so much
time baffled by what they encounter? Members of Murphy's
miniscule crew smile at each other, but seem baffled when
humans bare their teeth to greet the giant, Murphy-shaped
ship.
Brian Robbins, A.V. Club.
The Movie: 5
It seems that planet Nil is badly in need of salt, so they
sent a fist-sized sphere to Earth so that it can distill the
salt from our oceans, but the trinket gets thrown off course
and lands in a kid's fishbowl. A spacecraft is sent to find
out what has become of the sphere – that's Eddie there as
the spaceship, which is conveniently human sized. That's
also Eddie piloting the ship – he and his crew are just a
couple inches tall, and don't get out much. The ship soon
finds its (his) way to the home of fishbowl boy (Austin
Myers) and his single mom (Elizabeth Banks) and introduces
itself as Dave Ming Cheng. Meantime young Josh loses the
sphere to his nemesis at school and Dave is in a race
against time to locate it and get on with his mission. The
only problem is that, if he succeeds, it would be the end of
our planet as we know it.
Image:
7/8
The first number indicates a relative level of excellence
compared to other Blu-ray video discs on a ten-point scale.
The second number places this image along the full range of
DVD and Blu-ray discs.
Despite exceedingly high bit rates in the upper 30s, the
image is only pretty good: it’s reasonably sharp, but not
exquisitely resolved. A fine fuzz pervades - not that this
material screams out for better resolution. I assume this
all has to do with the way the movie was photographed and
processed. There are some scary close-ups of Eddie Murphy
that ought to seem more like real skin. I've seen some
pretty smooth skin in my time, but even with serious makeup
we ought to be able to get more texture than this: DNR or
some other business to assure us of his alienhood?
Audio & Music:
6/6
You'd think a movie about aliens come to Earth would offer
more audio interest that this but, in fact, this is mostly a
front-directed mix. There are the occasional surrounding
opportunities when the sphere scatters itself here and there
and when various commotions take place on board Dave, but I
found them unconvincing as to location. A salesman tells
Dave that putting on headphones is like having a subwoofer
in your head. Not.
Operations:
3
Dual layer Fox discs take a while to load, even on a PS3,
but once on board we get to the main menu quickly. Top Menu
permits direct bypass of promotional material. Fox is
experimenting with a new chapter search design, where only
one scene thumbnail at a time is viewable. I don't feel that
the increase in scene size outweighs the loss of strategical
navigation. Beyond that, I had some serious problem with
some of the extra features, the most important of which was
an inability to navigate within the extensive Crew Profiles.
Excepting this difficulty, the idea is a good one, where
each crew member comes on camera to explain his or her
mission – very droll. But once I began with any member of
the crew the remainder of the feature was totally on
autopilot: nothing but a return to the menu could allow me
to chose a different starting point in the profiles. Not
done with me, there was no audio on two of the three Fox
Movie Channel featurettes. I've encountered this snag once
or twice before on Fox Blu-rays and I continue to think it
may have something to do with the peculiar way I've
configured my surround system.
Extras:
4
Included is a fairly routine making-of piece that covers
casting and production. The Fox Movie Channel Presentation
with Brian Robbins is worth a look. (see also: Operations).
Bottom line:
6
Meet Dave might be thought of as The Return of Galaxy Quest
meets Woody Allen's Everything You Always Wanted to Know
About Sex. Unlike Norbit, also directed by Brian Robbins,
this movie is at least breezy and good-natured. In case, you
forgotten, Murphy is quite good at physical comedy
(something like Steve Martin in All of Me?) and there's no
latex suit to moderate his shtick. There's considerable
opportunity for Murphy to strut awkwardly and open wider,
wider, widest.
Leonard Norwitz
November 27th, 2008