Review by Brian Montgomery
Studio:
Theatrical: Koninck
Blu-ray: BFI
Disc:
Region: FREE!
(as verified by the
Momitsu region FREE Blu-ray player)
Runtime: 1:44:54.999
Disc Size: 44,601,378,098 bytes
Feature Size: 28,229,769,216 bytes
Video Bitrate: 31.99 Mbps
Chapters: 12
Case: Standard Blu-ray case
Release date: May 17th, 2010
Video:
Aspect ratio: 1.66:1
Resolution: 1080p / 23.976 fps
Video codec: MPEG-4 AVC Video
Audio:
DTS-HD Master Audio English (German + Afrikaans) 2065 kbps
2.0 / 48 kHz / 2065 kbps / 24-bit (DTS Core: 2.0 / 48 kHz /
1509 kbps / 24-bit / DN -4dB)
Subtitles:
English, none
Extras:
• 'Inside the Institute: An In-Between
World': journey into the film's creation
with the Quays, Mark Rylance and Alice Krige
(30:59)
• On the set of Institute Benjamenta (2000,
16 mins, DVD only)
• Institute Benjamenta trailer
• Eurydice She, So Beloved (11:05)
• Songs for Dead Children (24:02)
• The Comb (18:05)
• Fully illustrated booklet of
newly-commissioned contributions
The Film:
The Institute Benjamenta, the imaginary
academy that is the setting of the Quay
Brothers' first live-action feature film, is
a decrepit training ground for butlers
situated deep in a misty forest somewhere in
central Europe. It is here that Jakob von
Gunten (Mark Rylance), an aspiring butler,
enrolls for instruction in "the divine duty
of servants." Once ensconced, he joins less
than a dozen other dedicated students in
repeating the same absurd, monkish rituals
over and over under the stern tutelage of
the school's founder, Herr Benjamenta
(Gottfried John), and his sister, Lisa
(Alice Krige).
...."Institute Benjamenta," which was
adapted from a novella by Robert Walser, is
a purposely ambiguous allegory crammed with
symbols -- pine cones, deer heads, severed
forks, a mysterious goldfish bowl -- that
can be read any number of ways. Mixing
quasi-religious symbolism with a mood of
gothic horror, the film could be taken as
everything from a spoof of German horror
movies to a mock Christian allegory.
Excerpt of review from Stephen Holden
located HERE
Image:
NOTE:
The below
Blu-ray
captures were taken directly from the
Blu-ray
disc.
The image on this disc is exactly what Quay
fans had hoped for. As the accompanying
booklet tells us, the print used in this
release comes from a pair of 35 mm prints of
the film (one fine grain, the other low
contrast) and was fully restored to remove
dirt, scratches, and stability issues. The
image has a lovely grain structure as the
screen captures can attest to, and the
cinematography in each scene shows the sort
of careful and meticulous attention that the
Quays are known for. The image is very sharp
and you'd be very hard pressed to find any
fault with it. Indeed, since the final print
was overseen and ultimately approved by the
Quays, we can be fully confident that the
image is as it was in theaters. Overall,
it's a stellar job.
Audio & Music:
While the HD mono track likely won't blow
anyone away, this wasn't a film that was
made to test the limits of your stereo
system. Instead, the audio on this disc
seems perfectly acceptable for a slow and
contemplative film. The music, dialogue, and
sound effects are as crisp and clear as can
be, and there's really nothing to complain
about audio wise. The optional English
subtitles do a wonderful job without
blocking the image. There are, however,
non-removable subtitles when the characters
speak German or Afrikaan.
Extras:
The disc comes with a wealth of extras.
First, there's a 25 page booklet with
outstanding essays by German scholar and
Robert Walser expert, Samuel Frederick in
which he discusses the influence of the
author on the brothers, and Eastern European
cinema expert, Michael Brooke on the their
history. Additionally, the booklet contains
a correspondence, notes on the music and
biographical essays. Next, there's a short
documentary on the making of the film in
which the Brothers Quay appear on camera and
discuss their influences, along with the
film's stars. Finally, aside from the
theatrical trailer, there are three short
films by the duo that I believe were
previously unavailable on DVD. Of these, I
found "Songs for Dead Children" to be my
favorite, but it's great to have them all in
HD! Note, that that DVD also comes with the
2000 documentary "On the set of Institute
Benjamenta", but since my screener only
included the BD, I can't comment on it.
Bottom line:
While I must admit that this wasn't my
favorite effort by the Quays, it's still a
very intriguing work with delicate and
gorgeously composed cinematography. Those
interested in their animation won't find
much here, but they will find a gorgeous
work with an aesthetic sense that is
uniquely Quay-ian. This is a film that I
couldn't take my eyes off of, and the work
put in by the disc's producers is laudable.
Oh, and who can not enjoy a performance by
the magnificent Gottfried John? I highly
recommend anyone interested in the film to
give it a shot. Also, be aware that this is
one of the first titles that will be
released by the BFI in a dual format
edition. Instead of separate releases of the
Blu-ray and the DVD, both are included in
package here for the price that you would
normally pay for just one.
Brian Montgomery
April 28th, 2010