:
It was only 13 months ago that Miramax/Disney released this
movie on Blu-ray, so what's different about this new
edition? While there are nominal differences in respect to
the audio mix: 5.1 DTS-HD (48 kHz/24-bit) - which, for some
reason, my PS3 reads as DTS HD-MA - vs. the earlier 5.1
Uncompressed (48 kHz/24-bit), the new edition offers a 5.1
dub in Spanish – a nice touch considering where the events
take place. The AVC codec remains the same with slightly
higher bit rates. It appears to have been subtly remastered
for "better" contrast control, even though I see little
difference in my comparative caps. Much the same can be said
for the audio, which I cannot confirm is perceptibly better.
In any case, it's the uniquely disposed extra features that
make this release a true "Collector's Edition."
Excerpt of review from LensView: DVDBeaver.com located HERE
CLICK the BELOW 3 CAPTURES TO SEE COMPARISONS OF 2008
Blu-ray vs. 2009 Blu-ray
Extras:
9
In addition to the three Bonus Features included in last
year's Blu-ray release (The Making of No Country for Old
Men, Working with the Coens and Diary of a Country Sheriff,
the Collector's Edition has two new features: Josh Brolin's
Unauthorized Behind-the Scenes video is a deadpan Coenesque
parody of such featurettes in which the actors relate their
"true" feelings about working with each other and the Coens.
The other is a collection of some 16 interviews and
conversations from October 26, 2007, five months after
Cannes, but a couple weeks before general U.S. distribution,
to February 9, 2008, just a couple weeks before the Oscars,
which bestowed Best Picture, Director and Writing honors.
These segments are of various lengths (from 3 minutes to an
hour) with the press and the Coens or members of the cast
(Josh & Javier, mostly), or both, originating on TV, the
radio and other venues.
After watching or listening to a few of these I came to
realize that the hardest part of an actor's job is the press
conference. It must test one's patience and creativity to
field the same question repeatedly in ways that seem fresh
to each audience. After all, how many different answers can
there be to: "So what was it like working for two
directors?" or "Javier, how did you prepare for the role of
a psycho-killer?" Partly out of respect for the actors and
the Coens, I imagine, some interviewers find new ways to
explore these and other more fascinating aspects of
movie-making. For these we can rely on the likes of Charlie
Rose, Spike Jonze and Elvis Mitchell, but others have their
moments as well. There's something to be said for the
earlier interviews since the buzz about the movie was just
getting started and everyone involved was still fresh. As
Oscar time approached, you could sense the cautious optimism
the room.
I am tempted to summarize each of these many interviews, but
it seems this would defeat the purpose or at least dilute
the experience. You all know what these sorts of
conversations are like: simply add the Coens into the mix –
with one important advisory. Depending on the venue, they
can be as forthcoming as they are always intriguing. And,
yes, both of them can speak.
Bottom line:
9
In my review of last year's Blu-ray edition I wrote: "Only
the med-fi Extra Features preclude a Highest Recommendation".
But I would urge picking up anyhow, unless you're gambling
on a future double dip. And to my surprise, here it is,
sooner than I would have expected. Clearly there is nothing
about the image or sound that spells "upgrade," so it's all
a matter of bonus features that, though still in standard
definition, are remarkable for their novelty. This edition
certainly gets a thumbs up for first-timers, but for those
who already have the previous edition, I would recommend it
for serious cinephiles.
Leonard Norwitz
April 5th, 2009
|
|

Coming to 4K UHD by Criterion in
December 2024:

|