I believe both Simon of the Desert and The Exterminating Angel are available in a French DVD set but I do not own to compare. This Criterion DVD has original mono sound and optional English subtitles.

Extras: A Mexican Buñuel is a 55-minute documentary by Emilio Maillé made in 1997. It centers on the years Luis Buñuel spent in Mexico making many lauded films. At less than an hour it seems too short to fully cover the topics broached. Certain masterpieces like Los Olvidados and Simon are covered with interview excerpts from sources directly involved in the projects. This is an excellent primer for those keen on the directors essential Mexican work. We are also given a short interview with actress Silvia Pinal, who also played Viridiana, as well as 'The Devil' here in Simon. She gives her bright-eyed reflections on the production. There is also a great 40-page liner notes booklet featuring a new essay by critic Michael Wood and a reprinted interview with Buñuel.

Without forming a debate this may be another of Buñuel's best films - with the certain potential for a larger critical acceptance of this had he been able to complete it as a full feature. It was his last work in Mexico and even at only 45 minutes it shows his usual depth and some incredible cinematography by native Mexican Gabriel Figueroa.  I think the film probably warrants a commentary and am a bit surprised that one wasn't included.

The vast majority of Buñuel's films have reached DVD accessibility with Criterion producing the lion's share - with the best transfers and most viable extra features. I believe I am partial to the Mexican period as my personal favorite and hope Criterion continue with more exposure from that selection of work - or even through an Eclipse boxset.  This particular DVD of Simon of the Desert is essential.

Gary W. Tooze