Search DVDBeaver

S E A R C H    D V D B e a v e r

directed by various individuals


There are more than 700 “Star Trek” episodes, and there are ten features. Even for dedicated Trekkies, there is a lot of “Star Trek” to watch. When you consider the vast amount of paraphernalia that clutters the “Star Trek” market, the franchise can seem intimidating to casual sci-fi fans.

With this in mind, Paramount is releasing “Fan Collective” themed sets with episodes selected by fans at A few years ago, Paramount released a “Picard Collection”, but that set was released without much fanfare. However, 2006 is the franchise’s 40th Anniversary, so the studio is promoting “Fan Collective--Borg”, “Fan Collective--Time Travel”, “Fan Collective--Q”, and “Fan Collective--Klingon” as if they are “new” releases.

In the Star Trek Universe, the Klingons are a dark-skinned warrior race; they are also identified by their pronounced forehead and nose ridges. They wear armor-like clothing as well as prefer to use knives and swords whenever possible during fights. The Klingons have been used to represent the Soviets (see “Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country), but the emphasis on the warrior code as well as the premium placed on honor makes me feel that the Klingons are an update on ancient Chinese and Japanese cultural models.

In Star Trek chronology, humans/The Federation were at odds with the Klingon Empire for a few centuries before a disaster (i.e. the Chernobyl-like incident in “The Undiscovered Country”) forced the Klingons to make peace with the Federation. This resulted in the “domestication” of the Klingons--they were no longer as fearsomely deadly as before. In fact, they became “cute”, with viewers feeling affection rather than respect or dread for characters that were supposed to be proud warriors. The Klingons regained some of their “TOS” status when they became enemies with the Federation again during the “Deep Space Nine” years, but that enmity was short-lived.

Disc 1: “ENT--Broken Bow”, “TOS--Errand of Mercy”, “TOS--The Trouble With Tribbles”.

Disc 2: “TNG--A Matter of Honor”, “TNG--Sins of the Father”, “TNG--Redemption, Part 1”, “TNG--Redemption, Part 2”.

Disc 3: “DS9--The Way of the Warrior”, “DS9--The Sword of Kahless”.

Disc 4: “DS9--Trials and Tribble-ations”, “VOY--Barge of the Dead”.

I know that these compilations were assembled based on fans’ choices at, but did Paramount and CBS really have to follow the fans’ wishes so literally? “Borg” and “Time Travel” both have “VOY--Endgame”. “Borg” and “Q” both have “TNG--Q Who?”. “Time Travel” and “Q” both have “TNG--...All Good Things”. “Time Travel” and “Klingon” both have “DS9--Trials and Tribble-ations”. This is a terrible situation for people who don’t want to buy big box sets but want to have some “Star Trek” DVDs in their collections. Repeated episodes are a waste of time and space.

Also, there seems to be a dwindling number of episodes per set as they are released. This collection has only thirteen episodes. “Borg” has sixteen, and “Time Travel” and “Q” have fourteen each. Thirteen episodes can fit on three DVDs, but Paramount and CBS spread them out on four DVDs so that they can charge you the same price for less entertainment.

As Worf, Michael Dorn has logged the most performance hours out of all the “Star Trek” actors. He appeared in seven years of “The Next Generation”, four years of “Deep Space Nine”, and five big-screen adventures. (He played his own ancestor in the aforementioned “Star Trek VI”.) As Leonard Nimoy defined Vulcan mannerisms for later Vulcan portrayals, Michael Dorn defined what it means to be Klingon. Therefore, it makes sense that he gets the most representation in this box set.

Disc 2 features one of the best “Star Trek” story arcs ever. Worf is disgraced and accepts discommendation in “TNG--Sins of the Father” in order to preserve peace in the Klingon Empire. However, he regains his honor in “TNG--Redemption, Part 1” and “TNG--Redemption, Part 2” when the false nature of the accusations against his father are publicized. Disc 3’s “DS9--The Way of the Warrior” is the exciting introduction of Worf to another cast, and it features the first “real”, bruising battle between humans and Klingons in a long, long time.

Unfortunately, we get the rather boring “DS9--The Sword of Kahless” instead of any of the episodes dealing with Worf and Jadzia Dax’s courtship. The unconventional romance between a Klingon and a Trill gave the show a lot of heat and also provided viewers with interesting glimpses into Klingon culture.

Also unfortunately, the set only has one episode from “Voyager” even though Roxann Dawson played B’Elanna Torres for seven years on the show. B’Elanna often found herself at odds with her mixed Klingon-human heritage, and the “Voyager” writers got a lot of good mileage out of this internal conflict. It’s aggravating to see that this compilation does not have the episode in which aliens split B’Elanna into pure, separate Klingon and human entities, the episode in which Voyager comes across a Klingon ship that has traveled to the Delta Quadrant on a quest, or the episode in which B’Elanna tries to remove the Klingon genes in her unborn child.

“Star Trek: Fan Collective--Klingon” is targeted at casual viewers who are interested in the exploits of the franchise’s over-the-top warriors. Obsessive fans will pick up this set regardless of what I say, but aside from the text commentaries, you’re not getting anything that you don’t already have. Is this an unfair double dip? No. It serves its purpose, but if you have all of “Enterprise”, “The Original Series”, “The Next Generation”, “Deep Space Nine”, and “Voyager” already, then you don’t need this in your collection.

David McCoy

DVD Reviews


DVD Review: Paramount (4-disc) - Region 1 - NTSC

Big thanks to David McCoy for the Review!

DVD Box Cover

CLICK to order from:



Region 1 - NTSC

Runtime 686 min

1.33:1 Original Aspect Ratio
Average Bitrate: 6.3 mb/s
NTSC 720x480 29.97 f/s

NOTE: The Vertical axis represents the bits transferred per second. The Horizontal is the time in minutes.

Bitrate :

Disc 1

Audio Dolby Digital 5.1 English, Dolby Digital 2.0 surround English
Subtitles Optional English
Features Release Information:
Studio: Paramount

Aspect Ratio:
Fullscreen - 1.33:1

Edition Details:
• Audio Commentary for ENT--BROKEN BOW by Brannon Braga and Rick Berman
• Five Text Commentaries by Michael and Denise Okuda

DVD Release Date: 1 August 2006
Custom Cardboard Slipcase

Chapters 102




Comments Video:
All of the episodes are presented in their original broadcast aspect ratios, 1.78:1 anamorphic widescreen for “ENT--Broken Bow” and 1.33:1 for everything else. The quality varies widely, with the oldest episode (“TOS--Errand of Mercy”) looking soft and exhibiting faded colors and with the newest episode (“ENT--Broken Bow”) looking fairly sharp and exhibiting rich colors.

Some episodes look as if they were taken from interlaced sources or were mastered in 480i (this was fairly routine during the pre-DVD era since a lot of special-effects shots for TV shows were mastered in analog video).

You get the same Dolby Digital 5.1 English and DD 2.0 surround English tracks as you do with the previous DVD releases of these episodes. The older episodes are not as lively and immersive as the newer episodes, but the audio quality is more consistent across the board than the video quality is.

Optional English subtitles as well as optional English closed captions support the audio.

This set re-uses the audio commentary by Brannon Braga and Rick Berman as well as the text commentary by Michael and Denise Okuda for “Broken Bow” that were found in the “Star Trek: Enterprise Season 1” box set.

There are also text commentaries by Michael and Denise Okuda for “TOS--The Trouble With Tribbles”, “TNG--Sins of the Father”, “DS9--The Sword of Kahless”, and “DS9--Trials and Tribble-ations”. These are new text commentaries that were not included on previous DVD releases. It’s fun watching “Star Trek” with the Okudas as viewing companions. They have a sense of humor, and their extensive knowledge of “Star Trek” is always welcome.

The four discs are housed in a custom cardboard DigiPak case.

 - David McCoy


DVD Menus



Screen Captures

Thankfully, the reds don't bleed in ENT.









Combing indicated non-progressive transfer





The Under-represented B'Elanna Torres (Roxann Dawson)


DVD Box Cover

CLICK to order from:



Region 1 - NTSC


Hit Counter












DONATIONS Keep DVDBeaver alive:

CLICK PayPal logo to donate!

Gary Tooze

Thank You!