(aka "Simfonija Donbassa" or "Enthusiasm" or "The Dombass Symphony")
directed
by Dziga Vertov
Soviet Union 1930
Dziga Vertov’s hatred of the narrative film has been
well-documented. He was in search of some kind of pure cinema, a kind of
international film language that could be understood universally. For this he
invented the term ‘Kino-Eye’, which meant for Vertov that the camera is
superior to the human eye and it was only the camera which could record the
world as it really was. This doctrine led to Vertov’s greatest film ‘Man with
a Movie Camera’ (1929), a radical exploration of the possibilities offered by
the Kino-Eye. His style was so radical however it got him in trouble with the
Russian authorities who ordered him to temper his style and the result of this
‘change’ was ‘Entuziazm’ (1930). People familiar with ‘Man with a Movie
Camera’ will notice many similarities: the same filmic tricks
(superimpositions, split-screen, reversal etc.), the same odd camera angles
and of course the same reliance on montage, for Vertov remains one of the
pioneers of the Soviet Montage Movement. But there is one crucial difference
between these two films: Entuziazm is a sound film, where ‘Movie Camera’ was
silent.
The advent of sound only furthered Vertov’s interest in the technical
possibilities of film, because it opened up a whole new set of possibilities.
While not everyone immediately embraced the sound film, it was Dziga Vertov
who showed the world the possibilities of the use of sound in film. Vertov
uses sound in very imaginative and innovative ways throughout the whole film.
In fact, he explores the notion that the sounds of everyday life are just as
musical as ‘normal’ music years before composer John Cage began promoting this
idea. ‘Entuziazm’ is a film in which the images are constructed in close
harmony with the sounds, resulting in a close examination of the relationship
between image and sound. When looking at this film all these years later, one
realizes how little of the possibilities of sound are actually used in most
films.
‘Entuziazm’ may not enjoy the same popularity or critical appeal as ‘Man with
a Movie Camera’, but it is a totally unique and rewarding film in its own way;
a masterpiece of both early sound cinema and of the Russian avant-garde.
Theatrical Release: April 2nd , 1931 - Soviet Union
Reviews More Reviews DVD Reviews
DVD Review: Edition Filmmuseum - Region 0 - PAL
DVD Box Cover |
|
CLICK to order from:
|
Distribution |
Edition Filmmuseum Region 0 - PAL |
|
Runtime | 1:05:01 | |
Video |
4:3 Original Aspect Ratio
16X9 enhanced |
|
NOTE: The Vertical axis represents the bits transferred per second. The Horizontal is the time in minutes. |
||
Bitrate |
|
|
Audio | Mono | |
Subtitles | German, English (removable) | |
Features |
Release Information: Studio: Edition Filmmuseum Aspect Ratio:
Edition Details: Chapters - none |
Comments |
‘Entuziazm’
is the first release of what will become a series of releases from Edition
Filmmuseum, a collaboration between several film museums of the
German-speaking parts of Europe. There are two versions of the film here:
the unrestored print preserved in the former Soviet Union’s Gosfilmofond
and the more famous Peter Kubelka restoration from 1972. It is in fact not
so much of a restoration as more of a re-synchronization, because the
original print is totally out of synch and Kubelka tried to approximate
the film Vertov intended it to be. Exactly because this film relies so
heavily on sound, the contrast between these two versions is very
illuminating, and I am very happy both versions are included here. Other
than the re-synchronization, there has been no restoration of the images
however, and the result is a pretty damaged film: full of dots, lines and
speckles, although it’s certainly more than viewable. I asked the Austrian
Film Museum why they have done this and I got the following reply: ‘We are skeptical, though not opposed to digital image restoration; in this particular case, though, every further manipulation of the original film material (aside from a meticulous cleaning of the print and taking care of the perfect contrast and gradient balance of the transfer) was out of question since we wanted to preserve and present the film-as-an-artifact, a mutilated and battered testimonial to the fragility and durability of the celluloid medium.’ This totally makes sense of course, especially in the case of this film, which has had a highly tumultuous history. The sound is characteristic of early sound cinema, with again no digital cleaning up, but preserving the original mono as it was intended. The extra’s on the second disc are very interesting; the 65 minute documentary in which filmmaker Peter Kubelka discusses his re-synchronization and Vertov’s approach to the film is almost worth the money alone. All in all this is a splendid package and very likely the definitive version of this remarkable film, so I’m very much looking out for the upcoming releases of this promising new label. 2005 has already been a great year for avant-garde film on DVD, but this release makes my year yet another bit brighter. |
Screen Captures
DVD Menus
Subtitle sample
An example of the damage to
the film
DONATIONS Keep DVDBeaver alive:
Mail cheques, money orders, cash to: or CLICK PayPal logo to donate!
Gary Tooze
|
|
Thank You
Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm:
Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov's -
Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga
Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm -
Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD
Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga
Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm -
Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD
Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD
Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa
- DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga
Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm -
Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD
Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm:
Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov's -
Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga
Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm -
Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD
Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga
Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm -
Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD
Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD
Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm: Simfoniya Donbassa
- DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga
Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm -
Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD
Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov's - Entuziazm:
Simfoniya Donbassa - DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm
- Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa
DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov
Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya
Donbassa DVD Review Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review
Dziga Vertov Entuziazm - Simfoniya Donbassa DVD Review