Review by Leonard Norwitz
Studio:
Theatrical: Walt Disney Pictures
Blu-ray: Walt Disney Studios Home Entertainment
Disc:
Region: A
Runtime: 98 min.
Chapters: 13
Size: 50 GB
Case: Locking Amaray Blu-ray case
Release date: August 19, 2008
Video:
Aspect ratio: 1.78:1
Resolution: 1080p
Video codec: AVC
Audio:
Feature Film: English 5.1 Uncompressed PCM (48
kHz/24-bit). Bonus Features: English 5.1 DD
Subtitles:
Feature Film: English SDH; Bonus Features: English SDH &
French
Extras:
• Featurette: How to be a Rock Star (27:51)
• Featurette: Jonas Brothers: Real-Life Rock Stars
(15:42)
• Featurette: Introducing Demi Lovato (5:39)
• Featurette: Camp Memories (5:47)
• Featurette: "Hasta La Vista" – From Rehearsal to Final
Jam (4:53)
• Featurette: "Too Cool": Setting the Scene (3:34)
• Music Video: "Start the Party"
• Music Video: "We Rock"
• Sing Along with the Movie
• Camp Rock Karaoke
Exclusive to Blu-Ray
• The Camp Rock Set Tours (6:30)
• Theatrical Trailers in HD (x6)
The Film:
4
"Harmless" is a word that leaps to mind here. The moral
of this made-for-the-Disney Channel movie is stated loud
and clear – and it's a good lesson for kids of all ages:
Be yourself. Live your life, not someone else's. Be true
to yourself and your dreams even if it risks being
popular. It's this last directive that our heroine,
Mitchie Torres (newcomer Demi Lovato), learns in this
predictable, and occasionally fun Disney movie (whose
target audience, let's be clear, is several decades
younger than me.) With this confession out there for all
to see, I feel entirely irresponsible in saying that
even for a kid's movie, Camp Rock is rife with
underdeveloped characters whose motivation and response
to situations turns on a dime to satisfy the demands of
the plot. Let me describe an example while setting up
the situation: Mitchie strikes us as your average, sweet
high schooler, who is just dying to attend what would be
her first Camp Rock this summer. Camp Rock is sort of a
summer prep school for kids who want to make it in the
entertainment world. Mitchie's parents are unable to
afford to send her until her caterer mom lands a job
feeding the kids at camp. Their daughter gets in at a
significantly reduced fare, the only condition is that
she work part time in the kitchen. Once at camp, Mitchie
quickly runs afoul of mini-celeb Tess Tyler (Meaghan
Jette Martin as a Britney/Paris wannabe) and her small
group of Tess Tyler wannabes. Next thing you know
Mitchie feels she needs to invent a fake backstory about
herself to fit in. She registers appropriate anxiety at
just about every turn for the remainder of the movie for
her sins, often with the expected comic results – until,
of course, she is unmasked.
When Camp Rock alumnus-turned-rock star, Shane Gray (Joe Janos) shows up as an instructor, you would think that
his arrival would turn a few heads, but it seems it's
not that big a deal, especially for Mitchie, who for
reasons that certainly went right past me, finds herself
completely at ease with him on every occasion. Given her
status envy of Tess and her ilk, I found her cavalier
attitude about Shane (a boy, no less!) to be more than a
little improbable. (But what do I know? The script is
credited to five females and one male.) Anyhow, given
her confidence with Shane it struck me as contrived that
she would maintain her false history with him when an
opportunity presented itself to clear the air. Now I can
provide my own answers to this, but I would have
preferred a story for kids to have fleshed out and
clarified the issues, not turn them into pabulum.
Image:
5/7
The first number indicates a relative level of
excellence compared to other Blu-ray DVDs on a ten-point
scale. The second number places this image along the
full range of DVDs, including SD 480i.
Those sun-drenched Coppertone complexions, regardless of
race, get a bit tiresome here. That approach to make-up,
art design and photography worked better, I thought, in
the more stylized High School Musical 2. Not that it
should matter very much to its intended audience (he
said, dismissively) but this image is not really very
good. The photography lights just about every scene so
that we can see clearly and deeply into it, but the
image, as recreated on this blu-ray, is no sharper or
better resolved as the best 480i DVDs out there. Camp
Rock suffers mostly from fuzz factor. The image quality
is roughly comparable to HSM2 – with noticeably more
fuzz in the present instance. (In my revised scoring
system, HSM2 would get a 6/8).
Audio & Music:
6/6
Just when I thought there would be nothing to write home
about – the dialogue is crisp enough; the music track is
vivacious, but bass-poor as well as not particularly
dynamic; and the surrounds are, for the most part,
inactive – I noticed that the musical numbers are poorly
lip-synced. The editor cleverly cuts away each time it
becomes clear that these guys aren't really singing what
we hear, but by then it's too late.
Operations:
8
Walt Disney Studios Blu-rays continue their chapter-skipable
previews and promos before the loading of the feature
film begins (And once again I am grateful for the PS3).
As in some other recent Blu-ray DVDs, the menu lists the
length of the various segments along with a brief
description. And it's laid out so that even an adult
could use them without assistance.
Extras:
6
Camp Rock has nothing if not lots of featurettes of all
descriptions. Tips on How to be a Rock Star from the
Jonas Brothers and the cast is the highlight. It's a
clever, entertaining self-parody, if I do say so myself.
Then we have a segment all about the Jonas Brothers that
you can pack into 15 minutes; an even briefer bit behind
the scenes with Disney's hottest new talent, Demi Lovato
(now in pre-production on Camp Rock 2); a video
scrapbook of the cast, on & off the set; actors Jordan
Francis and Roshon Fegan follow "Hasta La Vista" from
rehearsal to finished product; Anna Maria Perez de Tagle
does likewise for "Too Cool". There are also optional
modes for a sing along and karaoke modes. The two music
videos: "Start the Party" and "We Rock" with Jordan and
the cast, are in execrable SD picture quality, which,
thankfully, cannot be said of the other bonus features.
The Camp Rock Set Tour, exclusive to the blu-ray
edition, is really just another backstage featurette,
but in 1080p. The running gag is that Joe Jonas makes
ten appearances like he's some sort of drop-in celebrity
instead of simply one of the cast.
Bottom line:
6/2
I'm going to go out on a limb here and guess that Camp
Rock isn't really much of a movie even for its intended
audience. It makes for interesting comparison to HSM2 in
that the earlier movie is more polished, but the
characters more two-dimensional. I found
the characters in Camp Rock to have more potential as
real people, but that the script fails to deliver the
promise. There are a couple of nice songs and the cast
has obvious talent, but I vote: Thumbs Down. As for
kids, tweens and older: I say again: Harmless.
Leonard Norwitz
August 19, 2008