Review by Leonard Norwitz
Studio:
Theatrical: Shochiku
Blu-ray: Funimation Entertainment
Disc:
Region: A
Runtime: 102 min
Chapters: 21
Case: Standard Blu-ray case
Release date: May 13, 2008
Video:
Aspect ratio: 2.35:1
Resolution: 1080p
Video codec: AVC
Audio:
Japanese Dolby True HD 6.1; English Dolby True HD
5.1
Subtitles:
Feature Film & Bonus Features: English
Extras:
• Behind the Scenes:
• Storyboards
• Weapons Introduction
• Shinobi Art - Manjidani
• Shinobi Action – Sumpu Castle Fight
• Original Trailers & TV Spots
• Funimation Coming Attractions
The Film:
7.5
You might think of Shinobi as Romeo and Juliet set
in medieval Japan. Two ninja families, long at each
others' throats, live in hidden villages. One, the
Iga, live in a relatively wooded area alongside a
lovely stream; the Koga are mountain people, living
in cliffs, not unlike the Pueblo Indians of North
America. One day, by chance, Gennosuke (Jo Odagiri),
the favorite son of the Koga comes across the
favorite daughter, Oboro (Yuki Nakama) of the Iga.
They declare their love for each other, fully aware
that their destiny lies elsewhere. This turns out to
be an understatement.
The time is 1614 and the ruling administration has
long known of the remarkable fighting skills of a
shadow people whose whereabouts are unknown but
whose martial arts skills are legend. In fact, the
Tokugawa Shoguns been able to keep the peace for the
past 400 years, but now they feel threatened by
these shinobi, and plot to bring about their demise.
Their plan is simple, depending on the shinobi's
lotalty, honor, and their one reason for living: to
fight, for they have trained since birth to hone
their special skills, which are more like
superpowers than mere martial arts. Crouching
Tiger's Li Mu Bai would indeed marvel at their
abilities. The Shogun declares that each clan will
choose their five best fighters to have it out in
the forests, plains and mountains - to the death.
The one left standing is promised to have some
remote impact on the line of royal succession. While
it is clear to us and to some of those chosen – not
least Gennosuke and Oboro – that something is amiss
here, the others are driven, like lemmings, to their
ultimate destinies.
Like Shakespeare's play, the story of Shinobi is
permeated with tragic ironies. Unlike Shakespeare,
the movie version does not dwell on the lovers, but
on magic and politics. The romance is taken for
granted – and may, for American audiences be felt to
be lacking and so the tragedy is that much less
felt. That said, the various duels and fights of one
against many are staged with imagination, and their
outcomes are rarely obvious.
Image:
8.5 (8~9/9)
The score of 8.5 indicates a relative level of
excellence compared to other Blu-ray DVDs. The score
in parentheses represents: first, a value on a
ten-point scale for the image in absolute terms;
and, second, how that image compares to what I
believe is the current best we can expect in the
theatre.
The photography and production design is
exceptional. Color and contrast: likewise, leaning
in many scenes toward a vivid saturation in keeping
with the magical aspect of things. The picture is a
little soft, but filmlike. In comparison to
Shochiku's Region 2 SD-DVD, it is much, much
sharper. I was quite disappointed with the Japanese
DVD when it came out a couple years ago and worried
that the problem might lie with the original film
elements. Rest assured – not so.
SD-DVD TOP vs. Blu-ray BOTTOM
SD-DVD TOP vs. Blu-ray BOTTOM
SD-DVD TOP vs. Blu-ray BOTTOM
SD-DVD TOP vs. Blu-ray BOTTOM
SD-DVD TOP vs. Blu-ray BOTTOM
SD-DVD TOP vs. Blu-ray BOTTOM
Audio & Music:
8/8
Funimation offers not only the original Japanese
audio track, now in Dolby True HD 6.1, but an
English dub in 5.1. The audio is good, without
bringing down the house – but, then, Shinobi is
really not the kind of movie where bombast is much
present. Instead, the audio mix concentrates on
creating atmospherics, like the rushing of a stream
or the swishing of a falcon's wings as distinguished
from the flight of a shinobi through the forest.
Operations:
7
Straightforward, easy to use, unremarkable. One nice
thing that I'm seeing more of lately: the ability to
return to the main menu from anywhere in the bonus
features. I deducted points only for the lack of
imagination for the menu graphics. The 2-disc Region
2 SD DVD did have good English subtitles for the
feature film, which are quite different from the
present BRD. I found the new translation clarified
some of the politics.
Extras:
5
While the 2-disc Region 2 "Iga Tsubagakure Special
Edition" had English subtitles for the feature film,
it had none for the bonus features, some 80 minutes
worth are here on the Blu-ray. The material is
interesting but not deep; the image is in variable
quality, but satisfactory 480i.
Bottom line:
9
At the time of this writing, Funimation is enabling
retailers to offer this Blu-ray DVD at a
fantastically low price, evidently to introduce
English-speaking audience to their line-up which,
funnily enough is mostly anime – making Shinobi an
odd choice for the purpose. (By the way, this
product is listed all over the place as a "Special
Edition". No such designation appears on the cover.
Evidently the word "special" in this context applies
to the price, not the content.) The Funimation BRD
is a great looking DVD, even if not demonstration
quality, and beats the original Region-2 SD DVD by a
greater margin than is usual for such upgrades.
Thumbs Up!
Leonard Norwitz
May 18, 2008