Review by Leonard Norwitz
20th Century Fox Pictures
Home Entertainment
Disc:
Region: A
Runtime: 111
Chapters: 24`
Size: 50 GB
Case: Standard Blu-ray case:
1 disc
Release date: April 29th, 2008
Video:
Aspect ratio: 2.40:1
Resolution: 1080p
Video codec: AVC @ 34 MBPS
Audio:
English 5.1 DTS Master
Lossless, French & Spanish
Dolby Surround
Subtitles:
English, Spanish, Cantonese,
Mandarin, Korean, none
Extras:
• The Wedding Party (14.5
min.)
• You'll Never Wear That
Again (7 min.)
• Jane's World (4.5 min.)
• The Running of the Brides
(5 min.)
• Deleted Scenes
The Film:
In one of the industry’s
fastest turnovers from
theatrical release (January
8) to Blu-ray (April 29),
Fox demonstrates that it
doesn’t take a blockbuster
special effects film to
qualify for high definition
release – which proves, not
so much the worthiness of
the movie in question, but
that Blu-ray is the go-to
format of the day. Katherine
Heigl (former New Mexican
alien and surgical intern)
stars in this lightweight
bit of romantic comedy about
Jane – always a bridesmaid,
never a bride. Jane seems to
have found her niche as
wedding coordinator to all
her friends. Her caretaking
role also extends to the
workplace, where she plays
nursemaid to just about
everybody, including Jane's
unsignificant other [sic] –
her all-too perfect boss,
George (Edward Burns), When
Jane's younger sister, Tess
(Malin Akerman), drops into
town for what was expected
to be a one or two week
visit, she soon catches
sight of said hunk, and it
falls on poor Jane to
introduce them: Boss George
(describing Jane's job at
work): "She's my right
hand." Sis: "Lucky her."
It's that kind of script a
times.
Meanwhile, Jane meets Kevin,
the ultimate wedding cynic
(James Marsden, channeling
Brad Pitt – if one can use
that word about the still
living.) Kevin compares
believing in marriage in
general and weddings in
particular to believing in
Santa Claus. Unbeknownst to
Jane, Kevin is actually an
ace writer, covering
weddings for the New York
Journal and goes after Jane
in much the same way as Jean
Arthur follows Gary Cooper
in Mr. Deeds Goes to Town –
with not dissimilar results.
The potential for romance
and comedy would be obvious
to the barely conscious, and
for the most part, the
story, situations and
performance goes about its
merry and often silly way.
Ms Heigl proves herself
quite capable in the
romantic comedy genre,
though I can't say I felt
she was all that comfortable
in heels and bridesmaid's
dresses – but, of course,
that must have been half the
point. She has an engaging
way with wordless replies
to situations. The scripted
sugar is tempered by the
inimitable Judy Greer as the
best friend who delivers a
much needed face slap in the
face – something the script
could have benefited from.
27 Dresses is harmless
enough and moves along
predictably and pleasantly
until the third act when
writer Aline Brosh McKenna
finds it necessary to
provide a psychosocial
explanation for Jane's
caring for others while
placing herself at the back
of a very long bus: Losing
what little edge the film
had until then (and, quite
frankly, I didn't believe
any of Tess's instant
conversion to humanity),
predictability quickly
devolves into formulaic
pabulum, as everyone's true
character is revealed and a
fairy tale lives happily
ever after.
Image:
Image : 8 (7.5~8.5/9)
The score of 8 indicates a
relative level of excellence
compared to other Blu-ray
DVDs on a ten point scale.
The score in parentheses
represents: first, a value
for the image in absolute
terms; and, second, how that
image compares to what I
believe is the current best
we can expect in the
theatre.
The saturated (but not very)
image is effectively (but
not very) presented in high
definition – though one
wonders why the bother.
Except for a few
breathtaking vistas of
Manhattan , neither the
movie nor the photography
hardly calls for it. The
reason is evident in my
opening remarks: High
Definition is becoming the
rule, rather than the
exception.
Audio & Music:
Audio & Music : 6/8
Given the possibilities of a
5.1 DTS Master Lossless
audio mix, the dialogue is
duller and foggier than is
generally the case in less
exotic presentations. On the
other hand, things really
come alive when the songs
take center stage, even as
only part of the soundtrack.
Operations:
Operations : 6
Here, as in many a Blu-ray
before it, I keep wondering
if I'm doing something wrong
or not doing something right
when I can't easily get to a
new special feature without
returning first to the main
feature.
Extras:
Extras : 6
Instead of a commentary,
there are three making-of
featurettes from 4-15
minutes long. I liked You'll
Never Wear That Again where
dress designer Catherine
Marie Thomas talks about the
assignment of a lifetime.
There is also one 5-minute
short titled The Running of
the Brides about the annual
one-day wedding gown
sell-off at Filene's
Basement in Manhattan where
we meet brides-to-be waiting
in line for the mad rush.
Apple: eat our heart out!
Bottom line:
Recommendation : 6
A familiar plot,
recollecting any number of
romantic comedy plots and
weddings (which could be
seen as much the same
thing), 27 Dresses makes for
a rentable, clean-cut date
movie or, if you see it that
way: your basic chic flic.
Leonard
Norwitz
April 20th, 2008