L  e  n  s  V  i  e  w  s

A view from the Blu (-ray) on DVDBeaver by Leonard Norwitz


A Little Background     Openers     


    Modus Operandi     The Scorecard:     

Audio     Operations    Extras     The Movie     Equipment




Sky Captain & The World of Tomorrow BRD

(Kerry Conran - 2004)





Studio: Brooklyn Films & Paramount (USA) / Paramount Home Entertainment (USA) 


Aspect ratio: 1.85:1

Feature film: 1080p / MPEG 2

119 minutes

Supplements: SD

1 disc



English: DTS HD 5.1

English DD 5.1

French: DD 5.1

Spanish: DD 5.1



English, English SDH, French and Spanish



• Commentary track by Producer Jon Avnet

• Commentary track by Creator/Director Kerry Conran, Production Designer Kevin Conran, Animation Director Steve Yamamoto, and Visual Effects Supervisor Darin Hollings

• Making of Featurettes

• Original six-minute promotional short film


17 chapters

Standard Blu-ray case

Release Date: October 13, 2006



Sky Captain & The World of Tomorrow

I imagine everyone has their favorite moments to rag about in Sky Captain.  The movie invites it so.  Nor can I help myself.  There is one that I find really bothersome and that one that merely puzzles me: The first is that Sky Captain, our action hero of the day and first line of defense in case of trouble, has known about these mechanical invaders for years yet it never occurs to any at his outpost, located just beyond the city, to have planes up in the air when an aerial attack was imminent.  So when his base is wiped out following the invaders' initial attack on the city, I did not think: a foreshadowing of Pearl Harbor, I thought "What an Idiot!" and promptly lost all sympathy.  The second is not nearly as troublesome, but it is nevertheless inexplicable: After the first attack on NYC, the newspapers read: March 13, 1939, yet the three movies playing in town are The Wizard of Oz, Wuthering Heights, and Kings Row, which had opening dates of August 17 and April 13 (both in 1939) and April 18 (1942).  I can understand the use of The Wizard of Oz for the sake of irony, but the others – why them, when plenty of other recognizable titles could have been chosen that would have actually been playing in New York on that date.


When it arrived in theatres in September of 2004 Sky Captain & The World of Tomorrow was hailed as the latest and greatest idea to blend live action and computer-generated backgrounds.  It promised to be the perfect tool for comic book and action heroes.  The fact that it flunked at the box office was not unexpected once we saw the result.




Sky Captain & The World of Tomorrow

The Score Card


The Movie : 7

It is the eve of the Nazi invasion of Europe.  As important scientists around the world mysteriously disappear, Chronicle reporter, Polly Perkins (Gwyneth Paltrow) comes upon information that leads her and ace aviator, Sky Captain (Jude Law), who happens to be her estranged romantic liaison, on the trail of the psychopathic mastermind, Dr. Totenkopf.  Their adventure takes them halfway around the world: to the snow-capped Himalyas, to the sea below and the sky above.  Will Polly, Sky Captain, and aviatrix Frankie Cook (Angelina Jolie) arrive in time before Totenkopf is able to carry out his plan to destroy the world?  Is the Pope catholic?  Is Polly Perkins one of the dumbest, though utterly charming heroines this side of Dale Arden?


While there is a modicum of suspense, Sky Captain & The World of Tomorrow stands or falls first and foremost on the merits of its art direction and effects and, secondarily, on it screenplay.  The former is unique and certainly achieves its goal of a new genre, blending in comic book fashion, live action and computer generated backgrounds.  The live action image is deliberately diffused - I assume partly to achieve an intended fantasy look, but also to hide the seams between the live and drawn.  The deco art direction and costuming recalls the serials of the forties as well as German expressionism (as in Metropolis), while the screenplay brings back memories of Buster Crabbe as Flash Gordon.  Sky Captain has more wit and more sex, but it's just about as inane – to the point that it's just as silly to criticize it in those terms.


Image : 7 (6/9.5)

The score of 7 indicates a relative level of excellence compared to other Blu-ray DVDs.  The score in parentheses represents: first, a value for the image in absolute terms; and, second, how that image compares to what I believe is the current best we can expect in the theatre.


As just mentioned, the image has a unique look: a kind of colorized black & white.  It is also consistently diffused.  These factors, and its high contrast, blown-out image is enough to keep it from being a contender in the world of HD.  If the transfer from HD Video were perfect, how could we know based only on the evidence?  I think that it's pretty much identical to the theatrical film as I remember it.   But once we tumble to the look of the film, it is effective at creating a seductive world apart from any reality we know.  High marks for that, at least.











Audio & Music : 8/7

Edward Shearmur's score is appropriately supportive but, otherwise, unremarkable.  I winced for a moment or two at its being so blatantly a John Williams' clone, and then moved on.  I found the music and effects tracks, though convincing, to lack the impact of the best DVD audio to date, at least in the 2-channel mixdown.  Dialogue was clear enough, though submerged in the battle scenes.


Empathy : 6

I suffered a tug of war for nearly half the film before letting go of my "need" that the film look like a high definition movie.  Seeing as how this was a Blu-ray disc, after all, and even if the resolution was probably as good as can be, it was tough going.  But once I did, I found the look of it compelling.  The audio helped.  The screenplay was insufferable for the first few reels, and then I stopped listening to it as if these were actual people or even real fictional characters.




Operations : 8

The menu is straightforward, simple, easy to understand. One unusual thing, though: The Commentaries are accessible while the feature is running, but all the other Extra Features are not.  One must first migrate to the Home menu, then on to Extras.  This seems, at first glance, like a hassle, but it's not impractical.  The unexpanding thumbnails captured the essence of the corresponding scene – chapter titles would have been especially appropriate, considering the serial-like material.


Extras : 8

This is where this Blu-ray edition scores, with all the extra features we could want.  The two commentaries are worth giving a pass, even though they explain very academically how the graphics were accomplished and how they supported the vision of the art design.  Much better are the various making-of featurettes.  Included also is the six-minute promotional short created by Conran.



Recommendation: 7

The art design that is the only good reason to watch and enjoy this movie.  The image is so soft, it's hard to see this as a reason to upgrade from the SD.

Leonard Norwitz
September 12th, 2007





Casino Royale
Enter the Dragon


Hit Counter