The new 40th Anniversary (more appropriately 7 years, almost exactly, from the original DVD release date) is improved in every single area. The image (both are dual-layered) takes up almost 2 Gig more space in the new edition - improving the compression but the transfer is obviously new as well - everything is superior - bitrate, colors, detail and it has more information in the frame. There may be some red/black boosting in the Anniversary but that seems to be common practice nowadays in the world of SD production (redder skin tones). I'd love to see this in high-definition one day and it's certainly not out of the question if the film is ever championed for a successfully supported theatrical retrospective.

NOTE: there is another difference - either the new release is slightly vertically compressed (likely) or the old is slightly stretched. It didn't deter my viewing (I actually watched it twice) and I can't see it bothering anyone... but it should be noted.

Other areas of improvement are the inclusion of English subtitles as an option (the original had only French or Spanish choices), a rather unnecessary 5.1 audio bump option (that did have some rich moments), and three new featurettes as extras (see below).

In the supplements the same interesting commentary is included. Although recorded separately it's great to hear Jewison and Steiger give counter-points to his 'over-the-top' performance style etc. Raspy voiced Jewison informs us of many production details he overcame (lighting, screening for the titles etc.). But with the 40th Anniversary we have three new featurettes - about 40 minutes worth that seem better than standard filler - anyway, I enjoyed them much more than the usual fare.

This is an easy recommendation for under $15, even if you own the original (which is available at only $2 less ?!?). Great film - I LOVED seeing it again. It is so performance driven and has a fabulous script. Recommended!  

Gary W. Tooze